Fat Toni's Pizzeria

First and last time I would ever order fat Toni’s pizza prob worst pizza I have ever eaten really disappointed wasted the rest of it now feeling really sick awful!!

Ordered extra tomato sauce there wasn’t also fresh basil and chilli oil they weren’t added either, and the pizza was nothing like they used to be, and more expensive.

This is the second time we have been let down by Fat Toni. The first our food was over two hours late and apparently had been lost between being cooked and us. No apology given. The second time over an hour late and no apology...given. There won't be a third time. View menu

We have been loyal customers since you started up in Stroud but you’ve lost us now. Our order took over hours, the bases were different (chewy, tasteless) the toppings have completely lost their quality. Tonight was a complete waste of money. I usually...only write positive reviews so I’m hoping that this one may prompt you to reflect a bit.

Fat Toni's pizzas are not what they used to be when they were based in their previous shop. Toppings are mainly from tins or pickle jars and the dough and quality of baking is pretty standard. I loved their pizzas when they first started out...in Stroud but always thought the name sounded like a chain; sadly, the pizzas now taste as though they are from a chain as well.

A friend recommended this pizzeria to us, and we were not let down. We had noticed how busy it was on Saturday night as we walked by, but on Sunday evening it was much quieter, mostly takeout orders, I believe. The three of us decided to share a gigantic 20-inch pizza with various toppings, which was a fantastic idea as we were able to try different varieties. It was disappointing that there was no salad option, but our pizzas were fantastic - flavorful, perfectly cooked, and the best we've had in Stroud. View menu

Ordered for delivery at called at couldn’t find the address despite delivering here twice in the last two weeks. Offered to remake and re-deliver or refund, decided to give them the benefit of doubt and said remake and re-deliver. They did not re-make,...they sent a cold hard pizza an hour after it should have been delivered. Loved their offerings previously, but based on this for a that had to be topped up to make the delivery minimum, will not order from again, nor recommend, in fact will discourage anyone who asks.

The restaurant was clean and well presented, and we were warmly greeted. They had a varied selection of pizzas that were all very appealing! After much deliberation, we decided on a pizza that turned out to be the best I've ever had. The toppings were generous but not overwhelming (walnut, Gorgonzola, artichoke, pesto); everything tasted fresh and the crust was crispy and delicious. I can't wait to try more pizzas on the menu! They also offer a nice selection of sides. There were many children there, including ours, so it would be nice to have a children's menu available. The Pecorino wine we had was also excellent. Overall, I highly recommend this restaurant.

Very upset and disappointed- the email below was sent on September and prompted no response: My husband and I ordered a vegesaurus and a Yankee yesterday.  We both love Fat Toni's but yesterday wasn't up to the usual standards I don't know if...it's the new order format which confused us, but the pizza didn't meet our expectations. I ordered a wheat free vegesaurus I'm not sure if the dough was wheat free also there seemed to be not much gorgonzola on the pizza and the pesto didn't look right (no parmesan in it I usually love this one and it just didn't taste right.My husband said the Yankee was missing toppings and the ghost chilli jam he loves so much was sloppy it does not seem to have se... View menu