Phone: +441347868387
Address: Main St, Oldstead, YO61 4BL, York, United Kingdom
City: York
Dishes: 9
Reviews: 12973
Website: https://www.blackswanoldstead.co.uk
"Apparently The Black Swan has a Michelin Rising Star and is a AA rosette restaurant in so our hopes were high for a great evening meal. Sadly we were hugely disappointed as we paid through the nose for some very pretty but completely flavour free food.We started with the free range Free-range Chicken Terrine with Pea Mousse, English Quails Egg, Peas and Crispy Bacon and the Pan-fried Mackerel with Mackerel Fritters and Warm Pickled Vegetables. Both dishes were extremely well presented but, and it is a BIG but, they had little or no flavour. The Chicken was utterly devoid of any flavour at all, in fact, the only item on the plate that tasted of anything was the crispy bacon. The fish dish was little better, it was amazingly flavourless, the best item on the plate was the warm pickled vegetables. So onto mains… I had the Line-caught Wild Sea Trout with Crab Crushed Potatoes, Samphire and Sauce Vierge and my guest ordered the Slow-cooked Belly of Old Spot Pork with Roast Apples, Fondant Potatoes, Bacon and Thatcher’s Cider Foam. Once again the presentation was faultless but the portions were very small. The trout was overcooked and served on a bed of completely tasteless Samphire, the potatoes were over salty and the Sauce Vierge was again utterly flavourless. And this pattern sadly repeated itself for the pork, which was extremely greasy and once again was devoid of any taste at all.I have no idea how this establishment had managed to impress the assessors at both Michelin and the AA; this will remain a mystery to me. Maybe the chef was away when we visited? Who knows? But on the strength of our experience here, I’d recommend giving The Black Swan a wide berth."
All prices are estimates.