Marco's New York Italian Sheffield

12 West Bar Green, Sheffield S1 2DA, United Kingdom

🛍 Wine, Brunch, Drinks, Italian

3.3 💬 29 Reviews

Phone: +441143990990

Address: 12 West Bar Green, Sheffield S1 2DA, United Kingdom

City: Sheffield

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 29

Website: https://mpwrestaurants.co.uk

"Very disappointed with the whole experience, we chose the restaurant on the menu that was shown on open table app, however on arrival this menu was not a available and the overall choice was very poor. On arrival at the restaurant our reservation had not be received from the open table booking but they were able to accommodate us, the staff to customer ratio was very low making the service very slow and confused at times. The food when arrived, (we all took the steaks),was tasty but the accompaniments were very disappointing, only cherry tomatoes, no other vegetables or side orders available. In summary a very disappointing meal at £60 a head, the restaurant is living off the name and not off the service or food, we will not be going back."

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Maísa Maísa

Lovely surroundings, friendly staff and excellent food we'll be back!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

Pub quality food hiding behind a celebrity name, slow and inaccurate service. Very disappointing.


Sanskriti
Sanskriti

Fabulous !! I came for my birthday with my girlfriends . The service and food were fantastic . Highly recommended


David
David

Apart from the meatballs being cold in the middle and the waitress forgetting our drinks everything else was top quality


User
User

Not what you expect from a restaurant like that.very disappointed I Would rather go to coal or any other restaurants like that than here. Never go...


JudithR
JudithR

Unfortunately, this restaurant is no longer in business. Open Table may still be accepting bookings, but I would advise against making a reservation as it would be a wasted trip.


AlexP
AlexP

This restaurant is fantastic. It offers amazing value for money and is a great live music venue. Make sure to visit on Manhattan evenings, which are the last Friday and Saturday of every month.


Simão
Simão

We made a reservation through Opentable for a special birthday meal with our family, but when we arrived at the restaurant, we found out that it had closed down the previous week. We were very disappointed and our evening was ruined.


Iris
Iris

We were welcomed very nicely and shown to our table, the waiter was with us within a few minutes and took our order, Our wine and food arrived very promptly ,the meal was exceptional and well presented, We enjoyed our visit to this Restaurant and would visit again when in the area.


NYCTripper
NYCTripper

Very disappointed with the whole experience, we chose the restaurant on the menu that was shown on open table app, however on arrival this menu was not a available and the overall choice was very poor. On arrival at the restaurant our reservation had not be received from the open table booking but they were able to accommodate us, the staff to customer ratio was very low making the service very slow and confused at times. The food when arrived, (we all took the steaks),was tasty but the accompaniments were very disappointing, only cherry tomatoes, no other vegetables or side orders available. In summary a very disappointing meal at £60 a head, the restaurant is living off the name and not of...

Categories

  • Wine A curated selection of fine wines from around the world, offering rich reds, crisp whites, and elegant rosés to pair perfectly with your meal. Savor each bottle's unique aroma, flavor, and complexity.
  • Brunch A delightful blend of breakfast and lunch dishes featuring classic favorites and creative twists. Enjoy savory options like eggs benedict or opt for sweet treats like fluffy pancakes and fresh fruit.
  • Drinks Quench your thirst with our refreshing selection of drinks, from hand-crafted cocktails and fine wines to non-alcoholic delights, including sodas, juices, and expertly brewed coffee and tea. Perfect complements to your meal!
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Amex
  • Wine
  • Mastercard
  • Wi-fi Available

Similar Restaurants

Frankie Benny's

Frankie Benny's

The Valley Centertainment, Broughton Lane, Sheffield, United Kingdom

Pizza • European • American • Fast Food


"I was well impressed with this restaurant. I usually eat at F&B..and I really quick understand the differences between food and taste, between restaurants. I know also what is the standard for F&B. Bad service you keep to remember and will not make you a returning customer. This is the only restaurant in a 100 miles radius I never complained or my food was never raw. I also appreciated on my last visit a lady who was cleaning she looked more from management as she didn’t had an uniform, setting a good example in cleaning for her employees and customers by cleaning tables very thoroughly, all the spots covered. Well impressed by that especially as I work with Covid patients and I know how important is to be infectious free. The separation areas they build are important as well. The lady who was cleaning I didn’t manage to see her badge as she is a fast walker but she had a colourful mask , the only one who was actually wearing one and yes I know you can choose if you want to wear them but still for me was important as she was trying to protect others in a close environment with covid roaming around everywhere. I held myself for over 2 weeks to write this review as I was to busy but like I said I will be a returning customer.Kudos to her ! Kudos to all managers who are setting the bar high and lead by example! I eat here roughly every 2 weeks and I’m always very well treated. My favourite restaurant, if 10 stars were to be available, 10 stars from me! From the 3 restaurants that Sheffield has, this is by far the best one! Keep it up, guys!"